Skip to content

U.S. Justice Department Secures $102 Million Settlement In Francis Scott Key Bridge Collapse Lawsuit

U.S. Justice Department Secures $102 Million Settlement in Francis Scott Key Bridge Collapse Lawsuit

By [Your Name], Staff Writer | Updated October 24, 2024

BALTIMORE, MD — In a swift resolution to one of the most high-profile maritime disasters in recent U.S. history, the U.S. Justice Department announced a $101.98 million settlement with the owners and operators of the cargo ship Dali, just one month after filing a $100 million lawsuit over the catastrophic collapse of the Francis Scott Key Bridge.

The agreement, reached on Thursday, resolves federal claims stemming from the March 26 incident when the Singapore-flagged container vessel lost power and slammed into a support pillar of the 1.6-mile-long bridge, sending a 1,000-foot section plummeting into the Patapsco River. Six construction workers — Miguel Luna, Dorlian Ronial Cabrera, Carlos Roquel, Alejandro Hernandez Fuentes, Jose Nikolas Fuentes, and Maynor Yines Suazo Sandoval — lost their lives in the tragedy, which also disrupted one of the East Coast’s busiest ports and inflicted billions in economic damage.

Details of the Federal Settlement

The settlement amount of $101,980,000 falls just shy of the $103,078,056 in civil damages initially sought by the Justice Department under the Rivers and Harbors Act, the Oil Pollution Act, and general maritime law. The funds will be directed to the U.S. Treasury and several federal agencies involved in the response and cleanup efforts, including the Coast Guard and the Army Corps of Engineers.

“This settlement holds the responsible parties accountable for the costs borne by the American taxpayer in responding to this preventable disaster,” said Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General Brian Mizer during a press call. Mizer emphasized that the deal includes no admission of liability by Grace Ocean Private Limited and Synergy Marine Private Limited but ensures recovery of federal expenditures. He also noted the government’s intent to pursue punitive damages in ongoing litigation to deter future negligence.

Francis Scott Key Bridge collapse
The Dali strikes the Francis Scott Key Bridge on March 26, 2024, leading to its partial collapse. (AP Photo)

Background on the Dali’s Failures

The Justice Department’s original complaint, filed on September 18 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland, detailed a “series of catastrophic failures” aboard the Dali in the minutes leading to the 1:28 a.m. collision. Investigators found the ship experienced multiple power outages, including two blackouts the previous day while still docked in Baltimore’s port. Despite these red flags, the vessel departed without informing the U.S. Coast Guard, as required by law.

U.S. Attorney for Maryland Erek Barron described the companies as “well-aware” of the ship’s deficiencies. “The collision was caused by negligence that could have been prevented,” Barron stated. The Dali, a 984-foot behemoth carrying over 4,600 containers, veered off course after its engines failed, rendering propulsion and steering inoperable.

Ongoing Legal Battles

While the federal settlement marks a milestone, litigation continues on multiple fronts. Grace Ocean and Synergy have sought to limit their liability to $43.6 million under an 1851 maritime law, a move contested by victims’ families, the state of Maryland, and the city of Baltimore.

Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown filed a separate 50-plus-page lawsuit earlier this month, alleging the companies ignored known issues with the ship’s electrical systems. The state seeks unspecified damages for environmental cleanup, port disruptions, toll losses, and reconstruction costs, estimated at over $1.7 billion for a new bridge. A press conference with Governor Wes Moore highlighted the suit’s focus on preventing future “catastrophic and preventable” incidents.

Families of the deceased workers have also sued, demanding accountability beyond liability limits. A federal judge recently denied a motion to consolidate cases, with trials potentially slated for late 2025 or early 2027.

“This was one of the most catastrophic maritime disasters in Maryland history, and the failure of Grace Ocean and Synergy Marine resulted in unimaginable loss.” — Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown

Economic and Rebuilding Efforts

The bridge’s collapse severed a vital artery for 30,000 daily vehicles and halted 1.1 million tons of cargo monthly at the Port of Baltimore, the nation’s top handler of automobiles and farm machinery. Temporary channels have restored some traffic, but full port operations are projected to resume by early 2025.

Reconstruction, led by the Maryland Transportation Authority, is underway with a $1.9 billion federal aid package. Governor Moore has stressed a rapid rebuild, aiming for completion within four years to restore economic stability.

Industry Response

A spokesperson for Grace Ocean and Synergy called the Justice Department’s action “anticipated” ahead of a September 24 claims deadline. The companies maintain the incident was unforeseeable but agreed to the settlement to resolve federal claims efficiently.

The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) continues its probe, with preliminary findings pointing to inadequate maintenance and crew training. This disaster has reignited calls for modernizing U.S. maritime safety standards, particularly for aging vessels like the 13-year-old Dali.

As legal proceedings unfold, the focus remains on honoring the lost workers and fortifying infrastructure resilience. The settlement provides some financial relief to federal coffers, but the full cost — human and economic — endures.

Related Coverage

Table of Contents